Office (425) 484-8161 Client Login (opens external site) Planning Portal (opens external site)

Guide

Retirement income beyond the 4% rule

What the 4% rule is, where it falls short, and other ways to plan retirement income, Social Security timing and taxes on withdrawals.

Who this is for
People within about ten years of retirement, or already retired, who are planning how to turn savings into income
Reading time
9 minutes
Reviewer
Pending review by Chris Reid, ChFC

Last reviewed

BLUF (Bottom Line Up Front): The 4% rule is a back-of-the-napkin starting point, not a plan. It came from historical market data and simple assumptions. Real retirement is messier. Markets drop at bad times, taxes take a bite, spending changes, and you may live 30 years or more after your last paycheck. A written income plan shows where each dollar comes from, in what order, and what you will do when markets fall.

Key takeaways

  • The 4% rule is a rough guide for a first-year withdrawal that is then adjusted for inflation. It is not a promise.
  • Sequence-of-returns risk means a market drop early in retirement can do more damage than the same drop later.
  • Bucket, guardrail and income-floor approaches each handle risk differently, and each has tradeoffs.
  • When you claim Social Security, and which accounts you draw from first, can change your lifetime income and taxes.
  • The month and year you retire can open tax planning opportunities, if you have the flexibility to choose.

What the 4% rule is

Financial planner William Bengen studied historical US stock and bond returns. He looked for the highest starting withdrawal that would have lasted through every 30-year retirement period in his data. The answer was roughly 4% of the starting balance, with that dollar amount raised each year for inflation. Bengen has since updated his research, and Chris has written about that update.

Hypothetical, for illustration only: A retiree with $500,000 saved would withdraw $20,000 in year one, then raise that amount each year by inflation. This is simple math, not a projection of what any portfolio will do.

People like the rule because it is easy. It gives a ballpark answer to the questions Chris hears from almost every near-retiree: How much do I need, and when can I retire?

Where the 4% rule falls short

  • It looks backward. It is built on past US market history. The future may be better or worse.
  • It assumes a certain mix. The research used a specific blend of stocks and bonds. Your portfolio may look nothing like it.
  • It ignores taxes and fees. A $20,000 withdrawal from a pre-tax account is not $20,000 to spend.
  • It assumes steady spending. Many retirees spend more early on travel, less in the middle years, and more again on health care later.
  • It assumes a 30-year retirement. Retire at 55 and you may need longer. Retire at 70 and you may need less.
  • It does not tell you what to do when markets fall. A rule that never changes cannot respond to a bad year.
  • It can leave money unspent. In strong markets, sticking to the rule may mean you spend far less than you could have.

Sequence-of-returns risk

While you are saving, the order of good and bad years matters less. You keep adding money and buying in down markets. Once you start withdrawing, the order matters a lot.

Picture two retirees with the same average return over 20 years. One gets the bad years first. The other gets them last. The first retiree is selling investments while prices are down to pay the bills, so fewer shares are left to recover when markets bounce back. The second retiree has a cushion of growth before the bad years arrive. Same average, very different outcomes.

Chris calls this the fatal flaw of a buy-and-hold approach for people living off their savings. As he puts it, a 35-year-old can wait for markets to come back. Someone with a retirement date circled on the calendar may not have that time.

Common ways people try to manage this risk include keeping a cash reserve, being willing to trim spending in bad years, covering basic needs with steady income, and spreading investments across assets that do not all move together. Each of these can help. None of them removes the risk.

Three common income approaches

Buckets

You divide savings by when you will need the money. A near-term bucket holds cash and short-term holdings for the next few years of spending. A middle bucket holds more stable investments. A long-term bucket holds growth investments. You refill the near-term bucket over time.

Guardrails

You start with a withdrawal amount and set upper and lower limits. If your portfolio grows past a point, you give yourself a raise. If it falls below a point, you take a modest cut. The goal is to respond to markets instead of ignoring them.

Income floor

You cover essential expenses (housing, food, insurance, utilities) with steady income sources such as Social Security, a pension and, for some people, an annuity. Savings then pay for wants, like travel and gifts.

Three common income approaches compared
ApproachHow it worksPotential strengthsTradeoffs
BucketsMoney split by time horizonEasy to picture, near-term cash may reduce forced sellingRefill rules can be fuzzy, cash may lag inflation
GuardrailsWithdrawals adjust within set limitsResponds to markets, may allow more spending in good yearsIncome can change year to year, takes discipline
Income floorSteady income covers essentialsBasic bills are covered by predictable sourcesAnnuities can carry fees, surrender charges, less access to your money, inflation risk and dependence on the insurer's ability to pay

Many real plans blend these ideas. If an annuity is part of any recommendation, ask about every cost, how long your money is tied up, what happens with inflation, and how the person recommending it is paid.

Social Security claiming timing

Social Security is often the one income source that lasts for life and adjusts for inflation, so when you claim matters.

  • You can start as early as 62. According to the Social Security Administration (SSA), full retirement age is 66 if you were born from 1943 through 1954, rises by two months per birth year for 1955 through 1959, and is 67 if you were born in 1960 or later (SSA (opens external site)). Claiming before your full retirement age means a permanently smaller check. For people born in 1943 or later, each year you wait past full retirement age, up to 70, adds 8% (SSA (opens external site)).
  • For married couples, the higher earner's claiming age affects the surviving spouse's benefit for life.
  • Health, family longevity, other income and whether you will keep working all factor in. If you claim before full retirement age and keep working, part of your benefit may be withheld for a time. For 2026, SSA withholds $1 for every $2 you earn above $24,480. In the year you reach full retirement age, it withholds $1 for every $3 above $65,160, counting only earnings before that month. From that month on there is no limit (SSA 2026 fact sheet (opens external site)).
  • Breakeven math is useful, but it is not the whole story. The survivor benefit and protection against living a very long time count too.
  • If you also have a public pension, confirm how the two interact under current law. According to SSA, the Social Security Fairness Act, signed January 5, 2025, repealed the Windfall Elimination Provision and Government Pension Offset for benefits payable from January 2024 on (SSA (opens external site)). It helps people whose benefit was reduced by a pension from work not covered by Social Security. A public pension alone does not raise your benefit.

Taxes on withdrawals

Where your money sits decides how it is taxed when it comes out.

  • Pre-tax accounts (traditional 401(k), 403(b), 457 and IRA): withdrawals are generally taxed as ordinary income.
  • Roth accounts: qualified withdrawals are generally tax-free.
  • Taxable brokerage accounts: you generally owe tax only on gains, often at capital gains rates.

Other tax pieces to plan around:

  • Required minimum distributions from pre-tax accounts start at a set age that depends on your birth year. The IRS says the starting age is 73 for people who reach 72 after 2022 (IRS Publication 590-B (opens external site)). Confirm your own starting age with the IRS or your tax professional.
  • Part of your Social Security may be taxable depending on your other income.
  • Medicare premiums can rise with higher income. According to SSA, the adjustment generally uses your tax return from two years earlier, so 2026 premiums are based on 2024 income (SSA (opens external site)). Certain life-changing events can support a new decision.
  • Washington does not tax wages or most retirement income, but it does tax certain long-term capital gains. According to the Department of Revenue, starting with tax year 2025 the rate is 7% on the first $1 million of taxable Washington gains and 9.9% above that, above a standard deduction of $278,000 for 2025, adjusted each year for inflation (DOR (opens external site)). Real estate and certain retirement account assets are among the exemptions.

Chris is a strong believer in building tax-free assets where it makes sense, and in some cases that means choosing to pay some tax now at known rates. Tools like Roth conversions come with tradeoffs: the tax is due now, a conversion cannot be undone, it may raise Medicare premiums, and whether it pays off depends on future tax rates no one can know.

Why the month you retire can matter

Many people retire on a milestone, like January 1 or a work anniversary. That can be a fine choice, but the date has tax effects.

If you retire early in a calendar year, your earned income for that year may be low. A low-income year can open a window to:

  • Convert some pre-tax money to Roth at a lower tax cost.
  • Realize capital gains at lower rates.
  • Harvest losses to offset future gains.

Other timing details also matter: when your final paycheck and any leave cash-out are paid, pension start dates, when health coverage ends, and vesting or employer match dates. Working longer into a year means more salary but less room for these moves. Not everyone has the flexibility to choose, and the right month depends on your whole picture.

Questions to ask

  • What is my essential monthly spending, and what share is covered by steady income?
  • What is my plan if markets fall sharply in my first few years of retirement?
  • Which accounts should I draw from first, and why?
  • What Social Security claiming age makes sense for each of us, including the survivor benefit?
  • Would a low-income year near retirement create any tax opportunities for me?
  • What does any recommended product cost, and how is the person recommending it paid?

Income plan checklist

  • Track your current spending and split it into needs and wants.
  • Get your Social Security statements and any pension estimates.
  • List every account by tax type: pre-tax, Roth and taxable.
  • Choose an approach for market drops before they happen.
  • Map out a withdrawal order and review it every year.
  • Check your health coverage plan until Medicare starts.
  • Put the plan in writing and share it with your spouse.

Talk it through with us

A rule of thumb is a fine place to start, but your retirement deserves a plan built around your actual income, taxes and goals. If you would like to talk through your income plan, your Social Security timing or your retirement date, we are glad to help. The first conversation is no cost and no obligation.

Book a time here (opens external site)


This guide is for educational purposes only and is not individualized investment, tax, legal or insurance advice. Rules, limits and benefits change; confirm details with the relevant plan administrator and a qualified professional before acting. Advisory services are offered through Presidio Financial Group, Inc., DBA Capital Partners Wealth Management, an investment adviser registered with the Washington State Department of Financial Institutions. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training.