Office (425) 484-8161 Client Login (opens external site) Planning Portal (opens external site)

Guide

How to evaluate what you pay for financial advice

How advisers get paid, what fiduciary and fee-only mean, how to read Form ADV Part 2A and Form CRS, and questions to ask any adviser.

Who this is for
Anyone who works with, or is thinking about hiring, a financial adviser, broker or insurance agent
Reading time
8 minutes
Reviewer
Pending review by Chris Reid, ChFC

Last reviewed

BLUF (Bottom Line Up Front): You should be able to answer two questions about any financial professional: what am I paying in total, and what am I getting for it? Many people cannot, because costs are spread across advisory fees, fund expenses, commissions and insurance charges. Lower is not automatically better, and higher is not automatically worse. The goal is to see the full cost clearly and decide whether the value is worth it to you. Any adviser should be able to explain this in plain English, in writing.

Key takeaways

  • Advice is paid for in several ways: a share of assets, flat or hourly fees, commissions, or a mix.
  • Products carry their own costs, such as fund expense ratios and insurance charges, on top of any advice fee.
  • Fiduciary and fee-only describe how an adviser must act and how they are paid. Neither means there are zero conflicts.
  • Form ADV Part 2A and, where it applies, Form CRS spell out fees, services and conflicts. Read them.
  • Ask every adviser the same questions, including us, and get the answers in writing.

Why it is worth checking

Fees come out every year, whether markets are up or down. Small differences add up over decades, because money paid in fees is no longer invested for you.

Hypothetical, for illustration only: A 1% annual fee on a $500,000 account is $5,000 for that year. The same fee on a larger balance is a larger dollar amount. This is simple math, not a statement about what any adviser charges or what any account will earn.

The point is not to find the cheapest option. It is to know what you pay so you can judge whether you are getting value for it.

The main ways advice is paid

The main ways advice is paid
StructureHow it worksWhat to look at
Asset-based feeA yearly percentage of the assets the adviser manages, usually billed quarterlyThe dollar amount, any breakpoints at higher balances and which services are included
Flat or planning feeA set price for a plan, a project or an ongoing retainerScope of work, what happens after the plan is delivered and whether implementation costs extra
Hourly feeYou pay for time spentEstimated hours and whether follow-up is included
CommissionThe product company pays the salesperson when you buy, sometimes with ongoing payments afterUpfront and ongoing commissions, and whether the recommendation could be influenced by them
CombinationFees plus commissions, or different arrangements for different servicesWhich role the person is in for each recommendation

Costs inside the products you own

Even with a clear advice fee, the investments and policies you hold have their own costs:

  • Fund expense ratios: an annual cost built into mutual funds and ETFs. You will not see it as a bill, but it reduces your return.
  • Trading and account costs: transaction fees, bid and ask spreads, and custodian or account fees.
  • Annuity costs: these can include mortality and expense charges, administrative fees, rider fees and surrender charges if you leave early.
  • Permanent life insurance costs: cost of insurance charges, policy fees and surrender charges, which can be hard to see in a policy illustration.

Ask for an all-in number: advice fee plus product costs, in dollars, for the coming year.

What fiduciary and fee-only mean

Fiduciary

A fiduciary has a legal duty to act in your best interest. For investment advisers, that includes a duty of care (advice that fits you, based on a reasonable understanding of your situation) and a duty of loyalty (putting your interests first and disclosing conflicts). Brokers who sell investments are generally held to a different standard called Regulation Best Interest. Insurance agents follow insurance rules.

Two things to keep in mind:

  • Being a fiduciary does not mean there are no conflicts. It means conflicts must be disclosed and managed.
  • One person can wear more than one hat. Ask whether the person is acting as a fiduciary for every recommendation, including any insurance or annuity.

Fee-only

Fee-only generally means the adviser is paid only by clients, not by commissions from products. That removes one type of conflict. It does not remove all of them. For example, an asset-based fee can create an incentive to keep money under management rather than use it to pay off a mortgage, buy an annuity or keep a pension. Fee-based is a different term and can mean fees plus commissions. Our firm charges fees for investment advice and may receive commissions on insurance, which we disclose in our Form ADV. If any adviser, including us, also helps with insurance, ask how that part is paid and where it is disclosed.

How to read Form ADV Part 2A

Form ADV Part 2A, often called the brochure, is a plain-language disclosure every registered investment adviser must give clients. Sections worth reading closely:

Form ADV Part 2A sections worth reading closely
SectionWhat it tells you
Advisory businessServices offered and how much the firm manages
Fees and compensationHow you are charged, fee schedules and whether fees can be negotiated
Types of clientsMinimum account sizes and who the firm serves
Methods of analysis and risksHow the firm invests and the risks involved
Disciplinary informationAny legal or regulatory events
Other financial industry activitiesInsurance licenses, broker-dealer ties or other businesses that could create conflicts
Code of ethicsRules on personal trading and conflicts
Brokerage practicesWhich custodian holds your money and any benefits the firm receives from it
Client referrals and other compensationPayments for referrals or from third parties

According to the SEC's Form ADV Part 2 instructions, the brochure follows a fixed order of 18 items, from the cover page to financial information, and state-registered advisers must also answer Item 19, which covers topics such as management background and other business activities (SEC (opens external site)). Washington may have its own added requirements; the Department of Financial Institutions can confirm them.

Part 2B, the brochure supplement, covers the individual adviser: education, work history, other business activities and disciplinary history.

How to read Form CRS

Form CRS (the client relationship summary) is a short document of a few pages. It explains services, fees, conflicts, the standard of conduct and disciplinary history, and it ends with conversation starters you can use. Under SEC rules, SEC-registered advisers and brokers that serve retail investors must provide one (SEC Form CRS instructions (opens external site)). Many smaller advisers are registered with their state instead and may not have a Form CRS, so ask what they provide in its place. That includes us: ask which disclosure documents apply to our firm.

You can look up advisers at adviserinfo.sec.gov, brokers at FINRA BrokerCheck, Washington securities licensing through the Department of Financial Institutions, and insurance agents through the Washington Office of the Insurance Commissioner.

Weighing value against cost

Cost is only half the picture. Write down what you actually receive:

  • A written financial plan that is updated as life changes
  • Retirement income planning, including Social Security and pension decisions
  • Tax planning or coordination with your tax preparer
  • Insurance and estate plan reviews
  • Ongoing investment management and rebalancing
  • Regular meetings and someone who answers when you call

Then ask yourself whether what you pay matches what you get and what you want.

Questions to ask any adviser, including us

  • Are you a fiduciary at all times, for every recommendation you make to me?
  • How are you paid, by whom, and what will I pay in total dollars this year?
  • Do you or your firm receive commissions, bonuses or referral fees?
  • What are the product costs on top of your fee?
  • Exactly which services are included?
  • Who holds my money?
  • Do you or your firm have any disciplinary history?
  • Can I have your Form ADV Part 2A, Part 2B and, if you have one, Form CRS?
  • What would it cost me to leave, including any surrender charges?

A second look at what you pay

If you would like help sorting through your current costs, our firm offers a Current Management and Investment Fee Evaluation. It is designed to help you see what you are paying and what you are getting for it. Find it in our tools.

Talk it through with us

Asking about fees can feel awkward. It should not. If you would like to walk through your statements or ask us any of the questions above, we are glad to talk. The first conversation is no cost and no obligation.

Book a time here (opens external site)


This guide is for educational purposes only and is not individualized investment, tax, legal or insurance advice. Rules, limits and benefits change; confirm details with the relevant plan administrator and a qualified professional before acting. Advisory services are offered through Presidio Financial Group, Inc., DBA Capital Partners Wealth Management, an investment adviser registered with the Washington State Department of Financial Institutions. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training.